The Bible is called on to provide at least two clear
reasons (but not definitions) for forgiving: fear and gratitude.
The first incentive to forgive is that God commands it.
Refusing or stalling thus constitutes sinful behavior. This view of forgiveness
primarily as a religious imperative also tends to preclude a reflective
analysis of what forgiveness is or even how to do it. If God has commanded us
to do something, we need to obey without question or else risk angering God,
which can lead to consequences more severe than any ulcer.
The second motivation is due to gratitude. The
fact that we are all undeserving recipients of God’s forgiveness forbids us
from withholding forgiveness from those who have wounded us (so the argument
goes). We assume that since it was a good thing for God to forgive us, it would
likewise be a good thing for us to forgive others (again, definitional
ambiguity aside). Thus, whether it is out of obligation or thanksgiving, the
idea remains that forgiveness is something that must be done because “God says
so.”
--- Bryan Maier, Forgiveness and Justice: A Christian
Approach. 2017.