Saturday, July 6, 2019

Time to End Liberalism?

Liberalism cherishes liberty, but liberty has different meanings in different contexts. Thus for one person liberalism implies free elections and democratisation. Another person thinks that liberalism means trade agreements and globalisation. A third associates liberalism with gay marriage and abortion. Liberalism offers diverse recommendations for behaviour in the economic, political and personal fields, and on both the national and international level.
 

What is now common to populist and nationalist movements throughout the world is that even if they describe themselves as ‘anti-liberal’, none of them rejects liberalism wholesale. Rather, they reject the set-menu approach, and want to pick and choose their own dishes from a liberal buffet. Thus Trump is still very much in favour of free markets and privatisation, but he thinks he can have these goods while undermining multilateral cooperation and even free trade. China supports free trade, and its Belt and Road Initiative is one of the most ambitious globalisation projects ever envisioned – but it is far less enthusiastic about free elections. The British Brexiteers uphold democracy and have nothing against individualism, but they don’t like the idea of multilateral cooperation and of giving too much power to international organisations.
 
But if both liberalism and communism are now discredited, maybe humans should abandon the very idea of a single global story? After all, weren’t all these global stories – even communism – the product of Western imperialism? Why should Vietnamese villagers put their faith in the brainchild of a German from Trier and a Manchester industrialist? Maybe each country should adopt a different idiosyncratic path, defined by its own ancient traditions? Perhaps even Westerners should take a break from trying to run the world, and focus on their own affairs for a change?
 
--- Yuval Noah Harari, 21 Lessons for the 21st Century: 
'Truly mind-expanding... Ultra-topical' Guardian. 2018.  

Tuesday, July 2, 2019

How Governments Manipulate Public Perception Through Media Control

Russia does offer an alternative model to liberal democracy, but this model is not a coherent political ideology. Rather, it is a political practice in which a number of oligarchs monopolise most of a country’s wealth and power, and then use their control of the media to hide their activities and cement their rule.
 
Democracy is based on Abraham Lincoln’s principle that ‘you can fool all the people some of the time, and some of the people all the time, but you cannot fool all the people all the time’. If a government is corrupt and fails to improve people’s lives, enough citizens will eventually realise this and replace the government. But government control of the media undermines Lincoln’s logic, because it prevents citizens from realising the truth. Through its monopoly over the media, the ruling oligarchy can repeatedly blame all its failures on others, and divert attention to external threats – either real or imaginary.
 
When you live under such an oligarchy, there is always some crisis or other that takes priority over boring stuff such as healthcare and pollution. If the nation is facing external invasion or diabolical subversion, who has time to worry about overcrowded hospitals and polluted rivers? By manufacturing a never-ending stream of crises, a corrupt oligarchy can prolong its rule indefinitely. Yet though enduring in practice, this oligarchic model appeals to no one. Unlike other ideologies that proudly expound their vision, ruling oligarchies are not proud of their practices, and they tend to use other ideologies as a smokescreen. Thus Russia pretends to be a democracy, and its leadership proclaims allegiance to the values of Russian nationalism and Orthodox Christianity rather than to oligarchy.
 
 --- Yuval Noah Harari, 21 Lessons for the 21st Century: 
'Truly mind-expanding... Ultra-topical' Guardian. 2018.